In the case under discussion, the applicant entered the US on a tourist visa in December 2018 and, after an I-140 denial based on extraordinary ability and employer sponsorship, ended up out of status. Lawyers in the conversation agree on one thing: an approved I-140 alone doesn’t grant the right to change status, and trips on advance parole only complicate matters further. The approach that led to a dead end should be seen as a cautionary tale for anyone considering adjustment of status from a position of broken status.
How the Problem Arose
The applicant arrived in December 2018 on a tourist visa. Three to four months after entry, the green card process began under the extraordinary ability category (EB-3). Work authorization and advance parole were issued in parallel. The I-140 under that category was initially denied, but the I-485 remained pending. Later, when the applicant was already out of status per the I-94, the employer filed a new I-140 for a sales executive position. It was approved last week, but at the time the current adjustment of status request was reviewed, there was none pending.
According to the lawyer cited in the conversation, the first reason for the denial was failure to meet the extraordinary ability requirements: the claimed experience didn’t match what the category demanded. The applicant noted that initially they didn’t know about other options, and their original intent had been to study on a student visa.
Why Status Can’t Simply Be Restored
The key issue is the I-485 form and the applicant’s status at the time of filing. According to the lawyer in the conversation, filing an I-140 together with an I-485 without a valid status for adjustment of status generally doesn’t work: as a general rule, you need to be in status to adjust status in the US. An approved I-140 doesn’t resolve that issue.
In the case discussed, the original I-140 and I-485 filing likely happened without Form I-549 (E-45), which is needed to avoid accruing unlawful presence. The applicant only learned about it later, from their current lawyer. That’s why, according to those in the conversation, the denied I-140 and the associated I-485 are considered to have no legal effect.
How Long Out of Status
The answer depends on when the applicant last left the US. The conversation mentioned two possible dates: a last departure in November 2023 or late 2023, with the advance parole validity expiring in November 2024. The lawyers stated plainly that it’s impossible to determine for certain whether advance parole entries count toward resetting unlawful presence. By their estimate, the time out of status ranges from two to seven years, and once someone has been out of status for more than a year, the exact length stops being decisive.
It was also noted separately that if someone has been out of status for more than a year and leaves the country, a 10-year reentry bar can be triggered. In other words, crossing into Canada or Mexico isn’t a solution.
What Options Remain
The lawyers in the conversation concluded that there is currently no way to adjust status based on the approved I-140. The only option mentioned was marriage to a US citizen, but only if it’s a genuine, good-faith marriage. For most cases, adjustment of status requires being in status. The applicant also mentioned listing their current US address on the I-140 requests, so immigration authorities are likely aware they’re in the country.






Comments
Reader experience is useful, but it is not advice: check the rules on the official site.
No account needed: click Sign in, type any name, and you are done.