According to the reported case, at an H-1B consular interview the applicant was told that USCIS had revised the criteria for EB-2 NIW and his case no longer qualifies, even though the petition had been approved back in 2025. The beneficiary intends to challenge this decision in court. At the same time, a number of cases are not having their visas issued, and the consulate does not state a reason.
What happened at the interview
The H-1B case went through an immigration interview at the consulate. At the first interview, the applicant was sent to wait. When called again, it turned out that in USCIS documents the spouse was listed as the applicant’s daughter. According to the account, no such error was found in the I-140 and DS-260 forms.
At the third interview, the applicant was told that USCIS had revised the EB-2 NIW criteria and that the case no longer met them.
How, under the described procedure, an approval can be revoked
A petition approval cannot be cancelled unilaterally. Two documents are required: a USCIS decision and a consular officer’s decision to return the case to USCIS for reconsideration. During reconsideration, USCIS must either send a request explaining why the applicant does not meet the requirements, or issue an official notice of denial.
The beneficiary, who received approval in 2025, considers this procedure a violation of their rights as an applicant and is preparing a lawsuit. The process is expected to proceed first through USCIS, then through the courts.
Cases without visa issuance and without explanation
This is not happening with only one case. There are cases where, at the interview stage, the visa is not issued and the reason for the delay is not disclosed. At one interview, applicants directly asked whether the delay was related to the immigration pause. The answer was no. At another, they asked whether a check of finances and asset ownership was needed, and again received a negative answer.
The reason remains unclear. The practice of the company described, in its own words, is to test hypotheses and carefully experiment with decisions without putting the case at risk, rather than waiting for changes — for example, after the new Congress convenes in January.

Context: why the procedure lacks transparency
According to the account, the current procedure is opaque for several reasons at once. The immigration pause keeps changing, and its status must be constantly monitored. It is unclear whether consular training related to the new Public Charge rule has been completed. Certain visa categories are changing rapidly: the $100,000 fee was first cancelled, then a new one was introduced, at $100-plus thousand.






Comments
Reader experience is useful, but it is not advice: check the rules on the official site.
No account needed: click Sign in, type any name, and you are done.